Quote preview background for Douglas R. Hofstadter
People enjoy inventing slogans which violate basic arithmetic but which illustrate __eeper_ truths, such as _1 and 1 make 1_ (for lovers), or _1 plus 1 plus 1 equals 1_ (the Trinity). You can easily pick holes in those slogans, showing why, for instance, using the plus-sign is inappropriate in both cases. But such cases proliferate. Two raindrops running down a window-pane merge; does one plus one make one? A cloud breaks up into two clouds -more evidence of the same? It is not at all easy to draw a sharp line between cases where what is happening could be called __ddition_, and where some other word is wanted. If you think about the question, you will probably come up with some criterion involving separation of the objects in space, and making sure each one is clearly distinguishable from all the others. But then how could one count ideas? Or the number of gases comprising the atmosphere? Somewhere, if you try to look it up, you can probably fin a statement such as, __here are 17 languages in India, and 462 dialects._ There is something strange about the precise statements like that, when the concepts __anguage_ and __ialect_ are themselves fuzzy.
Douglas R. Hofstadter Gödel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid
Turn into a Quote Card

Quote Detail

People enjoy inventing slogans which violate basic arithmetic but which illustrate __eeper_ truths, such as _1 and 1 make 1_ (for lovers), or _1 plus 1 plus 1 equals 1_ (the Trinity). You can easily pick holes in those slogans, showing why, for instance, using the plus-sign is inappropriate in both cases. But such cases proliferate. Two raindrops running down a window-pane merge; does one plus one make one? A cloud breaks up into two clouds -more evidence of the same? It is not at all easy to draw a sharp line between cases where what is happening could be called __ddition_, and where some other word is wanted. If you think about the question, you will probably come up with some criterion involving separation of the objects in space, and making sure each one is clearly distinguishable from all the others. But then how could one count ideas? Or the number of gases comprising the atmosphere? Somewhere, if you try to look it up, you can probably fin a statement such as, __here are 17 languages in India, and 462 dialects._ There is something strange about the precise statements like that, when the concepts __anguage_ and __ialect_ are themselves fuzzy.
DH
Douglas R. Hofstadter

Gödel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid

Quick Answer

What this quote page tells you

This canonical quote page keeps the full saying, the attributed author, any linked work, and the topic tags together so the quote can be cited from one stable URL.

Related Quotes

More quote cards from the same area

"

Mind", can't make differences between real and not..., (OFF NOW THAT..., then that...), you are saying lie after lie..., then believing in false stuff. And thinking in positive sides so to scream not much as the other do, but as always you one moment scream you can't stop it... Now putting against me a knife and saying "Go away... give me my daughter... give me her back"..., don't you see the people laugh at you, don't you see it. Look their faces, with so many smiles, but they aren't people, they are from the army, off, off for god sake they are soldiers which have guns. Have killed few people, have taken your daughter and they are many as a number than you and your whole family... Probably this part as an General I must skip it, because it's logical however look it and from this side, nobody will sacrifice so you to be happy... you will die.. O, o, the poor little girl crying in front of the people, she just saw her mother pointing with a knife against the soldiers and now she is killed by one of the soldiers.